« Sunshine confusion in Council transition | Main | Puna Open house draws crowd »

Coqui 24/7? Get used to it

Puna resident Sid Singer wrote last month in Kauai's The Garden Isle newspaper about the folly of continuing efforts to eradicate coqui frogs.  In the article and on his Web site, CHIRP , Singer says the problem with coqui is our attitudes toward them, not the frogs themselves, which are here to stay and harmless to the environment. Singer also says attempts to eradicate the noisy frogs harm the environment more than the frogs themselves.

Singer never really got a fair shake on the Big Island with his against-the grain approach to the coqui and couldn't even get a review of his book in local media, perhaps because there wasn't enough space in the papers for the impossibly long title: "Panic in Paradise: Invasive Species Hysteria and the Hawaiian Coqui Frog War (Environmentalism Gone Mad!)."

But walking around Saturday's Puna Open House you could see that a lot of resources are being applied to coqui control. Yet the frog populations continue to grow and there seems to be no stopping them. Government officials and volunteers are blanketing areas with large amounts of expensive caffeine and lime and other proposed solutions but the critters keep coming back.

The most disturbing new coqui theory was being advanced by Leilani Estates' resident Jon Olson. Have you noticed a few chirpers starting a little earlier than sunset in the evening? Or maybe a few still chirping past daybreak if they weren't lucky the night before? Olson says these frogs are learning that they needn't fear the light as they have been conditioned to do where daytime predators would quickly devour them. They don't have that problem here, however, and when this gets around among the coquis, look out. Their calls could become a 24/7 thing in Hawaii and not just a nighttime nuisance.

So I'm starting to think more like Sid Singer even though the forest around my house is thick with coqui. Better to embrace them than go mad trying to kill them. Cease fire. The coqui have won.

Posted on Monday, December 4, 2006 at 10:33AM by Registered CommenterHunter Bishop in , | Comments12 Comments | References1 Reference

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

References (1)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    all about kulartinuminto and top news

Reader Comments (12)

Yes, the coquis have won. The time to deal with them was when the infestation first appeared, but that opportunity was missed. This is yet another example of how the abyssmally slow pace of government response to problems cripples the Big Island's efforts to cope with any number of pressing issues.

The usual pattern is to talk story forever and then finally realize that the problem is either beyond all help (usual result) or has gone away (almost never happens.) Whether by design or accident, this results in the politicians not having to take a possibly unpopular stand and the government workers not having to do extra work or learn to perform more efficiently. Lack of money has been a frequent excuse, but that one is not working like it used to.

There may be hope, though. The number of incumbents thrown out in the recent county elections should indicate that the status quo is not working for a lot people. Or it may just mean that another group of procrastinators and endless story talkers is getting their turn. We'll see.
December 4, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterRex
I am right up there behind Syd Singer backing him up 100% regarding coquis. Those frogs are harmless. They don't sting, bite or poison. Every time I had the chance to pass Kelly Greenwell's old nursery at the top of Palani Road at night, I would roll down my car window and slow down just so that I could hear singing coquis.
Coquis surrounded my mom's neighborhood in Panaewa 2 years ago but no one in the neighborhood is freaking out over them. If Hawaiians can live with them, then so can others. Syd's right, its an attitude problem.
December 4, 2006 | Unregistered Commenternativeroots
I think Coqui's are very annoying. We stayed at a hotel on Banyan drive in Hilo recently. It seems the Coqui's have overrun the Banyan trees down there.It was very unnerving the sound that they make.

I've also driven around Hilo at night. Luckily I don't live in the infested areas. As I would have a hard time sleeping.

That being said its not a attitude thing. The fault lies with the idiots who imported this horrible creature to Hawaii.
December 4, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterAaron Stene
The attitude has to do with how we perceive the sounds from coguis. If I hear them as "singing" at night vs "making noise" then they are no longer "unnerving" or "horrible" and I am then able to relax and allow them to sing me to sleep during the few times that I have had the opportunity to stay over in Hilo. I sure wish I had some coquis to drown out the human generated noise in my neighborhood..
With that being said, I support the continued Coqui
eradication. They are huge nuisance in my opinion.
They are not endemic to Hawaii and do not belong here.

I wonder if these suckers have any natural predators.
But that is not a viable option to introduce their predator
here.Remember the Mongoose....
December 5, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterAaron Stene
Well, out of curiousity, I attended one of those coqui killing meetings just to check out the equipment that they are using and the equipment plus the garb that one must wear for spraying is a big fat pain in the butt.I would need a truck to haul the spraying machine and cover myself up in suffocating gear and then after spraying I would have to make sure that that huge tank is rinsed clean or else the spray will harden like cement. Its really too much pilikia IMO and not worth it.There are many creatures here that are not endemic but we let them stay. The only fault with the coquis is their singing. If they didn't sing so loud, we'd let them stay too. Other animals and creatures have no problem with singing coqui just humans.
The coquis can be irradicated by releasing enough irradiated, infertile males into the infestations. The problem is that the state, who was supposed to inspect incoming plant shipments to protect the ecosystem, failed when the big box stores began importing plants on a massive scale. Let's go back to the source of the problem,and put a $5.00 charge on each imported plants. Don't let that money get into the general fund, but when the eradication fund gets large enough, Kill 'em all. There is also a bacteria killing all manner and species of frogs on mainland North and South America. Maybe that should be explored a little more.
December 5, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterDel Pranke
Scientists say that frogs are like the canary in the coal mine. Their presence is an indication of a healthy environment. Any decline in their numbers is a sign of environmental damage. The damage is usually manmade. When you kill the frogs, you also kill the environment.IWith that said, I think we are blessed to have a frog like the coqui in our islands because their presence through their singing lets us know that our environment is still a healthy one..
I recently visited The Big Island from California. I stayed out in the Puna area. Needless to say, the frogs calls were sooooo soothing. It's not like living near a loud expressway or in a college dorm, that's for sure. Maybe I'm not the typical tourist, maybe I just like loud nature, but I absolutely adore the sound of the Coqui frog's singing. I looked all over the island for a CD of their mating calls that I could bring home with me. I've never slept so well as I did when I was in Hawaii. Rather than trying to eradicate a species that is essentially harmless, (I just dont believe the hype that the coqui is the end of the world) why not try to profit from their presence? Their numbers are dwindling in Puerto Rico, ship some back there. Eco-tourism is huge right now. Organize Coqui hikes, nighttime walks with flashlights, provide a recording to those who go along.

But stop killing these cute, adoreable little harmless frogs. The attempts to kill them is doing far more damage than the frogs themselves are doing.
May 17, 2007 | Unregistered CommenterNicole
I grew up in Puerto Rico and also have lived in Hawai'i for six years between 1991 & 1997. The first time I heard a coqui frog singing was in Maui at one of the resort hotels in Kapalua around 1995.

I was mesmerized to hear the coqui since as I grew up in Puerto Rico we were taught that the coqui was very sensitive to its environment and it was therefore very hard for him to survive in another climate for long periods of time. I heard stories of people trying to get them to other places by plane or boat just to find them dead at the end of the trip.

In Puerto rico they are embraced an exploited as a national symbol, and for tourism. They are indeed harmless and will not cause any of the native species in Hawaii to dissapear as they feed on small insects only. If any, ia a benefit as they can keep insect populations in check.

I personally love to hear the song of the coqui and since in Florida they do not thrive, I miss hearing them.

If instead of trying to kill the frog, which will be futile as they lay thousands of eggs. Why not learn about it and make it part of Hawaii?

Learn from the Mongoose experience, many have tried to get rid of them by bringing in rats (what a great idea) and the Mongoose is in Hawaii to stay. So is the coqui frog.... Enjoy it! I certainly would.

Aloha
September 25, 2007 | Unregistered CommenterHugo Marrero
I was born, raised and educated in PR. In P.R the COQUI IS venerated and protected BY ALL. The COQUI symbolizes our culture and love for the island. I was unaware that our adored COQUI had immigrated to the Hawaiian's islands. As a child I was told many times that the COQUI could only survive in PR. I am horrified to read about how the coqui is been persecuted and killed in Hawaii. The COQUI is harmless specie, in no way or form a COQUI will ever do any harm to the environment. The COQUI is a harmless frog, and their singing is soothing and relaxing. Allowing people to kill the coquis is inhumane, and should be immediately stopped. This is just another example of how barbaric our human race can be. PLEASE PUT THOSE TAX DOLLARS IN PLACES WHERE THEY ARE NEEDED: SCHOOLS, EDUCATION AND TO IMPROVE HEALTH SERVICES.
April 2, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterLebh
JUST SEND THEM BACK TO US!! SEND ALL THE COQUIES BACK TO THEIR NATIVE HOME IN PUERTO RICO WE WILL BE WAITING FOR THEM WITH OPEN ARMS!!!
April 2, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterLebh

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.