Daily headlines

SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 29

Isles may face orchid shortage click here

FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 28

THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 27

Happy Thanksgiving!

WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 26

Matson cuts fuel surcharge again click here

TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 25

Inauguration slated for Monday in Hilo click here

OHA stocks down 28 percent click here

MONDAY, NOVEMBER 24

Stephens Media cuts state, national staff click here

Med pot users up 87% in Hawaii click here

661602-1400265-thumbnail.jpg

 

Lava pics click here
Eruption update click here
Hawaii Volcanoes National Park click here 

Campaign events

All candidates having campaign events in Puna are invited to submit information for publication in this column.

The 'best-connected journalist' in Puna.
-- Hawaii Island Journal 

The owner

I was a reporter for close to 17 years at the Hawaii Tribune-Herald until October 2005, when I joined the growing ranks of union leaders now formerly employed by the newspaper. (For more about what's happening at the Tribune-Herald, check out the Hawaii Newspaper Guild web site.) Since then I've been the Hilo unit representative for the Guild, a freelance writer, photographer, and blogger.  Puna has been my family's home since 1993.

Powered by Squarespace
« What blog is Rene reading? | Main | Jordan to limit minority damage »
Saturday
28Oct

Higa cast as heavy again; Sierra Club eyes County Council majority sweep

I hesitate to weigh in on things like the Stacy Higa dustup with Matthew Binder, a Brenda Ford supporter, at the Virginia Isbell fundraiser for earthquake-damaged Kona Community Hospital last Sunday. Charges fly back and forth and I wasn't there. I don't know what happened. The apparent lack of witnesses in published reports is puzzling, however. Where were Isbell's people? Did she in fact see what happened or not? The story was not clear. Yet whether she did or not, her casual indictment of Matthew Binder --  "he deserved it " -- must rank among the stupidest remarks a politician has made this year.

The Puna connection to all this of course is that it was an aide to Fifth District Councilman Gary Safarik who filed a harassment complaint against Higa in March for allegedly berating her to tears in an office incident for which Higa was exonerated later by the County Clerk. The Higa-Binder incident also just once again illustrates the highly charged atmosphere that Higa brings to the County Council, which Puna's 5th District candidate will have to deal with. Unfortunately it also puts the police in the middle of this childishness with harassment charges from both Binder and Higa to investigate.

The Honolulu Star-Bulletin added some intriguing details, like Binder's allegation that Higa is illegally helping the Isbell campaign. A Brenda Ford win certainly could endanger Higa's hold on the Council.  Binder, who wrote the Sierra Club's Big Island endorsements in September, said keeping pro-environment candidates Angel Pilago, Pete Hoffmann, and Bob Jacobson on the Council (already accomplished), while knocking off pro-development candidates Holschuh (also accomplished) and Virginia Isbell (now in a Nov. 7 runoff with Ford), would create "an environmentalist majority on the island’s most powerful governing body."

Maybe Higa's beginning to feel some of that heat.



PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (9)

My first reaction to this debacle is, this really should've never happened. Yes there is no laws against taking politicians pictures. But it seems like he really wanted to
push the issue.Stacey's response was inappropriate also.

I'm not trying to defend Stacey. All I'm saying no one is
a winner, everyone got pie on their face in result of this.
Also that Honolulu Star Bulletin article made no mention of
Higa allegedly illegally helping Mrs. Isbell's campaign.
October 29, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterAaron Stene
OK, this whole thing indeed seems childish, or high-school at best. One does have to wonder why Mr. Higa seems to keep turning up in these incidents. Also, if a well-known local politician attends a public event, do they have a right to object to being photographed? Was he afraid the photo would not be flattering? Or was he not wanting the fact he was there to be publicized? Assuming that Mr. Binder might have been provocative, was this the best way to deal with it? It all really raises a lot of questions.
October 29, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterWankine
Hunter, thanks for posting the Higa/Binder incident. It really hit me hard and I was emotionally distraught over it and felt insulted after finding out that Binder had filed charges. The WHT is famous for exaggerating their facts. I happen to know Binder and Higa. I was also there at the fundraiser helping everyone out and saw part of what happened. Binder was full of anger from the beginning, did not respond when I greeted him and made a sarcastic remark to me when I asked him about a letter to the editor that he wrote. Binder's intent was to cause harm to Higa by taking photos of him in order to expose them later. Binder is a former news reporter for NPR. It would be interesting to know how many photos he has of Higa. Hope they supbeona (sorry for the spelling) the camera. Also, it would be interesting to know more of Binder's past. How many complaints and lawsuits has he made? What kinds of settlements did he recieve? Some folks can make a living from doing these ugly things.
October 29, 2006 | Unregistered Commenternativeroots
Higa along with the rest of us were helping do fundraising efforts for the Kona hospital's earthquake damage. Higa's attendance was not illegal because he was there for the same reason Binder was there, to make the fundraiser a success. Sierra Club is spreading lies about Virginia. Shame on Janice Palma Glennie, Binder and the rest of them. I am not renewing my membership. By the way, it is my understanding that Binder is such a troublemaker, that even Brenda Ford's campaign has a problem with him.
October 29, 2006 | Unregistered Commenternativeroots
Let's assume that Mr. Binder is indeed a bothersome, provocative person. How does taking pictures of a public figure at a public event harm the public figure? If he didn't want people to know he was there, he should not have gone. If he was doing something embarrassing, he should have been more careful. Also, dealing with provocateurs in a dignified manner is skill that competent politicians use to their advantage.
October 29, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterWankine
Wankine, I believe Hunter answers your question in his writing. Binder is claiming that Higa was illegally helping Virginia at the Kona Hospital fundraiser which was sponsored by Friends of Virginia Isbell. Binder is a skilled reporter who can turn something clean into dirt.I am sure those photos were going to be used to harm Higa and make Virginia look bad.
October 30, 2006 | Unregistered Commenternativeroots
Another thing is that Binder says that Angel Pilago is pro environment. The problem with these Sierra Club folks is that they claim pro environment when it comes to some large tract of land, but use the land for a highway and they will back off and disappear. Apparently they don't want to know that highways are extremely ruinous to the environment (noise, safety hazard, etc.).
October 31, 2006 | Unregistered Commenternativeroots
Hmmm, if Higa brings a highly charged atmosphere to the council then the 5th District rep needs to be ready with a tough skin. Wonder who has it? Safarik? or Naeole?
October 31, 2006 | Unregistered Commenternativeroots
Sierra Club and County Council?
The Sierra Club (sometimes) endorses candidates -- it does not control anyone.
It takes a runaway imagination to think that an endorsement by the Club puts a Council Member in anyone's pocket.
When a Chamber of Commerce or union endorses a candidate where is the hoopla?
Are we looking at a Council with an environmental conscience? Maybe. Is that such a frightful idea? Maybe not.
November 4, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterJames Weatherford

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.